Why I'm Not A Republican nor Democrat

This post is a response to two posts by my Father-in-Law, Jackie. You can read his posts on "Why I Am a Republican" at Jackie Speaks. Jackie has a two part post describing why he is a Republican. To be honest, it is probably the clearest and best articulation of why anyone should be a Republican I have ever heard. This post starts as a direct response and becomes a more generic comment on my own political philosophy. It will help you understand the first half to read Jackie's post.

Feel free to leave comments and let me know what you think. Like I say below, my opinions are still being formed!

Why I'm Not a Republican nor Democrat

First, you have done an excellent job of explaining your point of view. As you pointed out in Part I, there may be some who would disagree with you. However, what strikes me as significant is that you have written in such a way that anyone who disagrees with you and wants to have any meaningful conversation will be forced to debate at the foundational levels of political and theological philosophy rather than simply stating, "I'm in favor of increasing tax on the rich" or "I support a government funded medical plan."

Personally, I find many areas of agreement with you. You list seven foundational points in Part II. I completely and whole heartedly agree with points 1-5 and 7. As one of my professors used to say, "Humans are good by nature, but sinful in nature." That is, we are made for great things and great good, but we have become broken through the Fall and are now subject to the effects of our brokenness. That is what makes the Christian faith so powerful: the ability to recognize and celebrate the beauty and goodness of humanity but still have a category for explaining why and how such evil can be done.

Point 6 ("freedom is a fundamental right and human responsibility") I also would agree with, especially the ways in which freedom is a responsibility. I am hesitant theologically to ascribe to humanity "rights." Rights are about entitlement. I don't see God through Scripture giving us rights. I see Him give us gifts. I see Him bestow on humanity great worth and dignity. I see God make promises to/covenants with humanity. However, you have wisely coupled rights with responsibility which is essential and since we need to engage the world on these issues, a more non-religious term like "rights" may be required.

If the Republican Party acted and lived out what you are describing, I would be very glad indeed. My concern is that it may be presuming too much to ascribe these foundational values to all or ever a majority of the Republican Party. The economic theory is definitely and decidedly distinct between Republicans and Democrats. However, voting for the Republican Party is not the same as voting for these principles, sadly.

Larger picture, my political philosophy is still be formed. My greatest sadness is that both Democratic and Republican Christians have sat back and looked to the government to fix problems in society. By all means, I hope and pray that government will be able to help alleviate suffering and fight for justice. The reoccurring fault in the Church, though, is that we look to the government first, then to the Church.

Government is by nature self-seeking. It promotes what is best for itself. As you pointed out, one of the goals of government is "ensuring the safety and security of the nation’s citizens." Such an aim will at times automatically lead a government into situations where the mentality is "us-them." To me, this is decidedly un-Christian. Any time the lives of some people are valued more highly than the lives of others, that is evidence of the fallen human condition.

Christians first call should be to BE the solution rather than to VOTE for a solution. It's not enough to vote for candidates to fix social problems. Instead Christian's must jump in to actually serving like Jesus did. Of course, such service will ultimately lead to political involvement.

I Christians' participation in government should be much more highly focused on advocating for justice, the poor, oppressed, the unborn, and any other issues that are near to God's heart rather than spending so much energy in partisan politics. When was the last time any of us (including me!) wrote a letter to our Congressperson or Representative letting them know how we feel they should vote on certain issues? Politicians want to be re-elected. If Christians (who still technically are a majority in the US, depending on how you define "Christian") simply starting advocating, we'd see more justice take place than if we all voted for any certain candidates.

We've sometimes been called "Sunday Christians" meaning that we only act like Christ on Sundays and the rest of the week we're just the same as the rest of the world. Politically, it's even worse. We're "election year Christians." We care when it's time to vote, but the other three years, we don't really do anything.

I'm a citizen and voter who is passionately pro-life (in all cases) and believes in an ideal world that economically conservative policies would produce the best long term results. I am also in favor of government that helps provide health care for those who cannot get any and social services to those who need them and allows immigrants and refugees to get citizenship.

In conclusion, I am not a member of either the Democratic or Republican party. At first this was simply because I had not decided which party to join. Today, it has become the intentional decision to join neither party. I simply cannot get away from the fact that if Jesus were still walking the earth today as he did in Palestine 2000 years ago, He would not be a Democrat or a Republican. I have a feeling He would have some very strong reproves for both parties, not to mention His church.

Pray for me that I would be able to follow Christ and live up to my ideals. Pray also that I would have wisdom in the upcoming election as there truly is no perfect candidate. Above all, pray for God's will to be done--and not just during the election, but each day.